Sugar cookies are a true holiday classic — buttery, golden, and made for decorating. Whether you’re hosting a cookie decorating party, filling dessert trays, or baking up gifts for friends and neighbors, sugar cookies are the kind of treat that always disappears faster than you think.
But before you dive into rolling and cutting, there’s one question every baker eventually faces:
How many sugar cookies do I actually need to make?
Let’s break down how many cookies to plan per person — whether you’re feeding a small group, a classroom, or a full-blown holiday party crowd.
Jump to:
Average Serving Size of Sugar Cookies
How many sugar cookies someone eats really depends on the occasion. A single sugar cookie can be anything from a dainty 2-inch round to a big frosted cutout the size of your hand. But in general, here’s a good starting point:
- For dessert trays or parties: 2–3 cookies per person (if there are other desserts)
- For cookie exchanges: 4–6 cookies per person
- For cookie decorating parties: 3–4 cookies per person (plus a few extras for broken ones!)
- For gifting: 4–6 cookies per person, packaged nicely
- For kids: 1–2 smaller cookies per child
A good rule of thumb is to plan about 3 cookies per adult and 2 per child if sugar cookies are one of several treats offered.
How Many Sugar Cookies to Make for a Crowd
Here’s an easy guide based on average-sized cookies (about 3 inches in diameter):
| Number of People | Light Dessert (2 cookies pp) | Standard (3 cookies pp) | Generous (4 cookies pp) |
|---|---|---|---|
| 6 people | 12 cookies | 18 cookies | 24 cookies |
| 12 people | 24 cookies | 36 cookies | 48 cookies |
| 20 people | 40 cookies | 60 cookies | 80 cookies |
| 30 people | 60 cookies | 90 cookies | 120 cookies |
| 50 people | 100 cookies | 150 cookies | 200 cookies |
| 75 people | 150 cookies | 225 cookies | 300 cookies |
| 100 people | 200 cookies | 300 cookies | 400 cookies |
Tip: Always make 10–15% extra, especially for cookie exchanges or decorating events. Between “taste tests” and a few accidental breaks, it’s better to have too many than too few.
Batch Planning Guide
Most standard sugar cookie recipes make about 24 cookies (2–3 dozen) depending on size and thickness.
Use this chart to scale your batches:
| Number of Cookies Needed | Approx. Batches to Make |
|---|---|
| 24 cookies | 1 batch |
| 48 cookies | 2 batches |
| 72 cookies | 3 batches |
| 120 cookies | 5 batches |
| 240 cookies | 10 batches |
| 360 cookies | 15 batches |
Pro tip: Chill your dough between rolling and cutting. This helps cookies hold their shape and keeps large batches consistent — a lifesaver when baking for a crowd!
Tips for Making Sugar Cookies for a Group
1. Use a large mixing bowl.
When scaling up, a big bowl (or even a stand mixer) helps you mix dough evenly without overworking it.
2. Cut efficiently.
Roll the dough to an even thickness and cut cookies close together to minimize scraps. Gather and re-roll leftover dough only once to avoid tough cookies.
3. Chill between batches.
If your kitchen is warm, refrigerate cut cookies for 10–15 minutes before baking to help them keep their shape.
4. Bake on parchment.
Lining pans makes cleanup faster when you’re baking dozens (or hundreds) of cookies.
5. Cool completely before icing.
A large wire rack setup or cooling grid helps speed up the decorating process when making big batches.
6. Assembly-line decorating.
If you’re frosting a lot of cookies, line them up on a parchment-covered table and decorate in batches — it keeps things tidy and efficient.
7. Storage matters.
Sugar cookies stay fresh for up to 1 week in an airtight container, or up to 3 months frozen (unfrosted).
Planning by Occasion
| Event Type | Cookies Per Person | Notes |
|---|---|---|
| Dessert Table | 2–3 | Offer a variety alongside other sweets |
| Cookie Exchange | 4–6 | Everyone will want extras to take home |
| Decorating Party | 3–4 | Include a few backups for breaks |
| Holiday Gifts | 4–6 | Perfect wrapped in cellophane or tins |
| Kids’ Event | 1–2 | Smaller cookies are best for little hands |
Final Thoughts
Sugar cookies might seem simple, but they have a magical way of turning any occasion into something special. Their buttery edges, soft centers, and endless decorating options make them a true holiday staple.
The golden rule:
- 2 cookies per person for dessert tables
- 3 cookies per person for casual gatherings
- 4–6 cookies per person for gifting or cookie swaps
When in doubt, bake a few extra — sugar cookies disappear fast, and there’s no such thing as too many when they’re buttery, sweet, and fresh from the oven.
Because honestly, no one has ever complained about having leftover sugar cookies.
Pin to Pinterest
Related
Looking for other recipes like this? Try these:
