There are good cookies… and then there are the cookies that stop people mid-sentence. You know the kind.

Someone walks into the kitchen, pauses, tilts their head, and asks,
“Okay, what exactly is happening in here? Because it smells unreal.”

That’s the magic of brown butter meeting melted chocolate and the cozy warmth of cinnamon drifting into the air.
That’s the sourdough discard adding depth you didn’t even know a cookie could have — without adding any sour flavor. Instead, the sourdough starter creates the softest, chewiest texture and helps the cookies stay tender for days.

These Brown Butter Sourdough Discard Cookies are the kind of recipe that doesn’t just sit quietly in the background — it announces itself. Thick, chewy, gooey, golden, and absolutely loaded with chocolate puddles that melt into the dough like tiny pools of happiness.

They’re the cookie you bake once… and instantly become known for.
The cookie people request for birthdays, holidays, “just because,” and especially whenever they hear you’ve refreshed your sourdough starter.

And somehow, despite tasting like something from a boutique bakery, they’re beautifully simple. No fancy steps. No special equipment. No complicated technique.

Jump to:

• Instructions
• Related
• Pin to Pinterest

Why You’ll Love These Cookies

These cookies don’t just deliver flavor — they deliver texture, aroma, and that nostalgic, cozy feeling that only really great cookies create. Here’s what makes them truly exceptional:

The brown butter magic

Browning butter transforms simple cookies into something gourmet. It brings toasted, caramelized, nutty notes that taste like a warm hug.

That perfect chewy-gooey balance

The sourdough discard makes the crumb dense and tender. The extra yolk makes the centers silky. The higher brown sugar content keeps everything chewy long after they cool.

Crispy edges that contrast beautifully

You get that perfect snap at the very edge, almost like toffee, before hitting a molten center.

A super soft cookie— NOT sour

Discard gives complexity, not sourness. It won’t make your cookies tangy or sour at all — it simply deepens the flavor and creates the dreamiest, softest texture.

They bake up thick

No thin, flat cookies here. Even without chilling, they stay plump — and with chilling? They’re bakery-worthy.

Versatile mix-ins

Stir in marshmallows for hot cocoa vibes, toffee bits for crunch, or chopped chocolate for dramatic melting pools.

They’re incredibly reliable

They turn out right every single time. And that’s exactly what you want in a signature cookie recipe.

Ingredient Breakdown

Understanding why each ingredient matters helps you customize, troubleshoot, and bake with confidence. Here’s the “why” behind the magic:

Brown Butter

This is the soul of the cookie.
As the milk solids brown, the butter transforms into a rich, aromatic base that tastes like caramel, hazelnut, and toasted sugar — all in one.

This is what makes people stop and say, “What’s that smell?”

Granulated Sugar + Dark Brown Sugar

Using both gives you the best of every cookie world:

• Dark brown sugar → chewiness, moisture, depth, molasses warmth
• Granulated sugar → crisp edges, caramelization, structure

The combination creates that perfect contrast between crisp edges and soft centers.

Sourdough Discard

This is where the texture magic happens.

Discard:

• Hydrates the dough
• Increases chew
• Helps prevent spreading
• Deepens flavor over time

It’s subtle but transformative.

Egg + Egg Yolk

The egg provides structure.
The yolk adds richness and that dreamy, chewy density.

Together, they create a cookie that’s thick and perfect.

Vanilla

A full tablespoon.
This isn’t just for aroma — it’s for rounding the flavor so every bite feels warm and buttery rather than overly sweet.

Flour

The amount here ensures these cookies are thick and not wafer-thin. Too little flour = spreading. Too much = dryness. This amount is exactly right.

Baking Soda

Works with the natural acidity of the sourdough to create lift, browning, and that beautiful crackly top.

Sea Salt + Cinnamon

Salt brightens the sweetness.
Cinnamon adds warmth that melts perfectly into the brown butter base.

You don’t taste cinnamon; you feel its coziness.

Chocolate Chips or Chopped Chocolate

Chopped chocolate melts into gorgeous pockets of gooeyness.
Chocolate chips hold their structure for texture.

Use both for a beautiful balance.

Instructions

Use this section for process shots, alternating between the step and image showing the step. Users don’t like seeing process shots cluttering up the recipe card, so include your process shots here.

Step-by-Step Instructions

1. Brown the Butter

Brown the butter slowly to develop its flavor — rushing it risks burning.

• Melt butter over medium heat
• Stir while it foams
• Keep cooking until golden, fragrant, and speckled with brown bits
• Remove from heat
• Cool for 10–15 minutes

Tip: If it’s hot enough to melt sugar instantly, it’s too hot.

2. Mix Browned Butter + Sugars

Pour the warm brown butter into a bowl.
Add both sugars.

Beat for 2–3 minutes until:

• glossy
• thick
• slightly lighter

This creates a base that gives the cookies their iconic chew.

3. Add Wet Ingredients

Mix in:

• the egg
• the yolk
• vanilla
• sourdough discard

The batter should look glossy, rich, and smooth.

4. Whisk Dry Ingredients

In a separate bowl, whisk:

• flour
• baking soda
• salt
• cinnamon

Whisking evenly distributes the leavening so the cookies rise nicely.

5. Combine Wet & Dry

Add the dry mixture into the wet ingredients.

Stir until:

• the dough is thick
• no dry streaks remain
• everything looks cohesive

Do not overmix — that leads to tough cookies.

6. Fold in Chocolate

Use a spatula to gently fold in:

• chocolate chips
• chopped chocolate
• optional marshmallows

Chopped chocolate gives dramatic pools; chips give structure. Together? Cookie perfection.

7. Chill the Dough

Chill at least 2 hours — but overnight is where the true magic happens.

Why chilling matters:

• discard hydrates the flour
• flavors deepen
• dough becomes scoopable
• cookies spread less
• the final texture becomes thick and chewy

This is a transformative step.

8. Bake

• Preheat to 350°F (175°C)
• Line baking sheet with parchment
• Scoop 3 tablespoon (70g) dough balls

Bake for 9–12 minutes until:

• edges are set
• centers still look glossy and soft

They continue cooking on the tray, so don’t overbake.

9. Finish

While warm:

• swirl a biscuit cutter around each cookie for perfect circles
• sprinkle with flaky sea salt
• rest on the tray 5 minutes

Then move to a cooling rack… if you can resist that long.

Step-by-Step Tips for the Best Cookies

1. Use warm — not hot — butter

Hot butter will scramble the eggs. Warm is perfect.

2. Chill your dough

Even 30 minutes helps.
Overnight takes them from “good” to “bakery-level.”

3. Use chopped chocolate

Chips hold shape.
Chopped bars melt into rivers.

4. Slightly underbake

If the center looks done in the oven, you’ve gone too far.

5. Stick to parchment

Silicone mats prevent spreading differently and can make cookies pale.

6. Space them out

These cookies bake thick and tall — give them room.

Variations

Hot Cocoa Sourdough Cookies

Add:

• ½ cup mini marshmallows
• ½ cup chopped milk chocolate

Dust finished cookies with cocoa powder for extra coziness.

Double Chocolate

Replace ¼ cup flour with cocoa powder.
Use dark chocolate chunks for intensity.

Salted Toffee

Add ½ cup toffee bits.
Finish with flaky salt.

Holiday Cinnamon Swirl

Add:

• extra ½ teaspoon cinnamon
• ¼ teaspoon nutmeg
• ¼ teaspoon allspice

Storage Instructions

Room Temperature

Airtight container
3–4 days
They stay soft thanks to brown sugar + discard.

Freezer (Baked Cookies)

Freeze up to 2 months.
Warm for 10 seconds to revive gooeyness.

Freezer (Dough Balls)

Freeze raw dough balls for 3 months.
Bake from frozen, adding 1–2 minutes to the baking time.

FAQs

Does the discard make the cookies sour?

NO — just more flavorful, chewy, and complex.

Can I use active starter instead?

Yes, same amount.

Can I skip chilling?

You can, but your cookies will spread more and lose depth. Even 30 minutes helps.

Can I use salted butter?

Yes — just reduce the added salt by ¼ teaspoon.

Why do my cookies bake up too puffy?

If chilled longer than 24 hours, add 1–2 teaspoons milk before chilling next time.

Why This Recipe Works

This recipe is designed scientifically for maximum flavor and bakery-quality texture.

Here’s why it works so well:

• Brown butter adds depth and richness.
• High brown sugar content ensures chewiness and moisture.
• Sourdough discard hydrates the dough, prevents spreading, and enhances flavor.
• Egg + yolk create chew and lift.
• Chilling strengthens the structure and intensifies flavor.
• Baking soda works with acidity for golden color and height.

Every detail is intentional — and all of it works together to create a thick, gooey, unforgettable cookie.

Final Thoughts

These Brown Butter Sourdough Discard Cookies are everything a homemade cookie should be — warm, deeply flavored, gooey in the center, crisp at the edges, and rich with layers of caramelized butter and melting chocolate.

They taste like the kind of cookie you’d find at a specialty bakery… but they’re simple enough to whip up on a weekday afternoon. And once you make them, they become your signature cookie — the one everyone remembers and asks for by name.

Keep your sourdough discard handy. You’re going to want to make these again and again.

Love Sourdough Discard Recipes? Try out some of my favorites:

Old Fashioned Sourdough Discard Cinnamon Rolls

Sourdough Discard Cinnamon Roll Focaccia Bread

Crispy Sourdough Discard Waffles

Related

Looking for other recipes like this? Try these:

Pin to Pinterest